Offend

Comments (3)

Comment Feed

A little quote...

"If you can't annoy somebody, there is no point in being a writer." - Kingsley Amis

KD 228 days ago

Offend? Hardly Required To Qualify As Art

While great art does at times challenge and does at times offend the entrenched elite, it is surely possible to name ten who did not offend - Tolkien, Toynbee, Fisk come immediately to mind, although Toynbee is now subject to objections that reflect more the standards and sensitivities of now than then, and Fisk is more respected than decried. Drinking hemlock is not required of art.

Peter McCann more than 2 years ago

Offend

As belated as this response is to Stephen Henighan's claim, like Peter McCann I find the "offend" thesis to be far too narrow, as are its supposed driving forces or impulses of "private demons" and "the nation. Henighan is obviously correct in suggesting that offending readers via one's demons and the channeling of a people or nation has been crucial to an incredible number of writers (i.e. Joyce, Doris Lessing, Jacques Poulin, Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Mordecai Richler, Murikami in The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle....) but his claims are far too prescriptive. And as much as I take McCann's point that, on the whole, a Tolkein or any number of other major writers throughout time have not initially been perceived as creating works that are offensive there is no transnational nor transhistorical guarantee that they will not be perceived as offensive in another cultural context or epoch.

David Leahy more than 1 year ago

---
KEEP IN TOUCH WITH GEIST

---
EMAIL
FIRST NAME
LAST NAME
PROVINCE




Submission Guidelines      Newsstands      The Geist Atlas of Canada      About Geist      Volunteer      Advertise     

Built with Metro Publisher™