Greyzone

Author: 
Christopher Grabowski
Teaser: 
Last year Christopher Grabowski returned to Poland, which is his native country, after an absence of ten years. He found Warsaw to be exciting and vibrant and a scene of great cultural activity. At a gallery opening he heard a well-known film director speak of the poverty he had seen twenty years earlier, amongst the coal dumps in the industrial and coal-mining district of Silesia, which is about half a day’s drive south of Warsaw. The film director assured Grabowski that conditions in Silesia were not like that today.
Teaser Image: 
Deck: 

Text by Mandelbrot.

Last year Christopher Grabowski returned to Poland, which is his native coun­try, after an absence of ten years. He found Warsaw to be excit­ing and vibrant and a scene of great cul­tural activ­ity. At a gallery open­ing he heard a well-known film direc­tor speak of the poverty he had seen twenty years ear­lier, amongst the coal dumps in the indus­trial and coal-mining dis­trict of Silesia, which is about half a day’s drive south of Warsaw. The film direc­tor assured Grabowski that con­di­tions in Silesia were not like that today. Grabowski, who has been doc­u­ment­ing dis­pos­sessed com­mu­ni­ties in Canada, decided to see for him­self, and he drove down to Silesia, which is a dense agglom­er­a­tion of indus­trial cities criss-crossed by a vast net­work of roads and high­ways, and began to ask around in bars and cafés. He was told that scav­eng­ing com­mu­ni­ties still existed, and over a day and a half of fruit­less search­ing, many help­ful peo­ple gave him direc­tions for find­ing the com­mu­ni­ties. Then he found what he was look­ing for at a dump half a kilo­me­tre from where he had begun the search, on a vast piece of ground over which peo­ple were labour­ing in the shadow of an end­less pro­ces­sion of huge trucks bring­ing in waste mate­r­ial from the coal mines.

Grabowski took his cam­era to the dump early the next morn­ing, in the falling snow, and intro­duced him­self to some of the peo­ple scav­eng­ing for coal, and he was not sur­prised to dis­cover that no one wanted to talk to him. A few peo­ple asked him for a smoke and he went back to town for a sup­ply of cig­a­rettes; by noon some of the peo­ple were speak­ing to him in a guarded fash­ion and by mid-afternoon some of the chil­dren had told them their names and had begun to talk freely of their life and their work at the dump, which con­sists of scrab­bling with bare hands in the icy rub­ble for the equiv­a­lent of about seven dol­lars a day. From time to time they warmed them­selves at a fire made from dis­carded plas­tic fur­ni­ture and old mattresses. 

As dusk approached, some­one said to Grabowski, who had kept his cam­era hang­ing around his neck all day, aren’t you going to take any pic­tures — you’re a pho­tog­ra­pher, aren’t you? And for the last hour of day­light Grabowski took pic­tures of the chil­dren and some of the adults at work that day at the dump. Some of these pho­tographs appeared in the Globe and Mail, along with an account of con­di­tions among the scav­eng­ing unem­ployed in Silesia.

It’s hard to believe that these pho­tographs were taken on an after­noon in 1999, and not in Stalingrad dur­ing World War ii, or north­ern France dur­ing World War i. They are like the mem­ory of a bad dream. We think of William Blake’s “dark Satanic mills,” and our con­text is the begin­ning of the indus­trial age, not the end of it. The peo­ple in these pho­tographs are invis­i­ble not only in Poland but every­where in the so-called “global” econ­omy. They are the newly dis­ap­peared, and to see them requires intense effort, for they are not ghosts emerg­ing briefly from the past: they are with us now; they are here. 

Image Groups: 
Date Published: 
August 27, 2008